Earlier this winter,
I met an investment banker who was diagnosed with a brain tumor five
years ago. He's a managing director at a top Wall Street firm, and I
was put in touch with him through a colleague who knew I was writing a
story about the potential dangers of cell-phone radiation. He agreed to
talk with me only if his name wasn't used, so I'll call him Jim. He
explained that the tumor was located just behind his right ear and was
not immediately fatal—the five-year survival rate is about 70 percent.
He was 35 years old at the time of his diagnosis and immediately
suspected it was the result of his intense cell-phone usage. "Not for
nothing," he said, "but in investment banking we've been using cell
phones since 1992, back when they were the Gordon-Gekko-on-the-beach
kind of phone." When Jim asked his neurosurgeon, who was on the staff
of a major medical center in Manhattan, about the possibility of a
cell-phone-induced tumor, the doctor responded that in fact he was
seeing more and more of such cases—young, relatively healthy
businessmen who had long used their phones obsessively. He said he
believed the industry had discredited studies showing there is a risk
from cell phones. "I got a sense that he was pissed off," Jim told me.
A handful of Jim's colleagues had already died from brain cancer; the
more reports he encountered of young finance guys developing tumors,
the more certain he felt that it wasn't a coincidence. "I knew four or
five people just at my firm who got tumors," Jim says. "Each time,
people ask the question. I hear it in the hallways."
It's hard to talk about the dangers of cell-phone radiation without
sounding like a conspiracy theorist. This is especially true in the
United States, where non-industry-funded studies are rare, where
legislation protecting the wireless industry from legal challenges has
long been in place, and where our lives have been so thoroughly
integrated with wireless technology that to suggest it might be a
problem—maybe, eventually, a very big public-health problem—is like
saying our shoes might be killing us.
Except our shoes don't send microwaves directly into our brains. And
cell phones do—a fact that has increasingly alarmed the rest of the
world. Consider, for instance, the following headlines that have
appeared in highly reputable international newspapers and journals over
the past few years. From summer 2006, in the Hamburg Morgenpost:
are we telephoning ourselves to death?
That fall, in the Danish journal Dagens Medicin: mobile phones affect the brain's metabolism. December
2007, from Agence France-Presse: israeli study says
regular mobile use increases tumour risk. January 2008, in
London's Independent: mobile phone radiation
wrecks your sleep. September 2008, in Australia's The Age:
scientists warn of mobile phone cancer risk.
Though the scientific debate is heated and far from resolved, there are
multiple reports, mostly out of Europe's premier research institutions,
of cell-phone and PDA use being linked to "brain aging," brain damage,
early-onset Alzheimer's, senility, DNA damage, and even sperm die-offs
(many men, after all, keep their cell phones in their pants pockets or
attached at the hip). In September 2007, the European Union's
environmental watchdog, the European Environment Agency, warned that
cell-phone technology "could lead to a health crisis similar to those
caused by asbestos, smoking, and lead in petrol."
Perhaps most worrisome, though, are the preliminary results of the
multinational Interphone study sponsored by the International Agency
for Research on Cancer, in Lyon, France. (Scientists from thirteen
countries took part in the study, the United States conspicuously not
among them.) Interphone researchers reported in 2008 that after a
decade of cell-phone use, the chance of getting a brain
tumor—specifically on the side of the head where you use the phone—goes
up as much as 40 percent for adults. Interphone researchers in Israel
have found that cell phones can cause tumors of the parotid gland (the
salivary gland in the cheek), and an independent study in Sweden last
year concluded that people who started using a cell phone before the
age of 20 were five times as likely to develop a brain tumor. Another
Interphone study reported a nearly 300 percent increased risk of
acoustic neuroma, a tumor of the acoustic nerve.
As more results of the Interphone study trickled out, I called
Louis
Slesin, who has a doctorate in environmental policy from MIT and in
1980 founded an investigative newsletter called Microwave News.
"No one in this country cared!" Slesin said of the findings. "It wasn't
news!" He suggested that much of the comfort of our modern lives
depends on not caring, on refusing to recognize the dangers of
microwave radiation. "We love our cell phones. The paradigm that
there's no danger here is part of a worldview that had to be put into
place," he said. "Americans are not asking the questions, maybe because
they don't want the answers. So what will it take?"